Shell vs Exxon vs BP: Three Oil-Company Gas Cards Compared
The three big oil-company gas cards are not equally available. The BP Rewards Visa saves 15 cents per gallon at BP and Amoco and is open to applicants. The ExxonMobil Smart Card+ saves 10 cents per gallon at Exxon and Mobil but no longer takes applications. The Shell Fuel Rewards Mastercard ties its discount to Shell's Fuel Rewards program. Here is how they compare.
Headline Summary
| Card | Open to applicants | Standing rate | Network |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shell Fuel Rewards Mastercard | Check Shell's current card offer | Per-gallon discount at Shell, tied to Fuel Rewards status; not re-verified this review | Mastercard (open-loop) |
| ExxonMobil Smart Card+ | No: applications no longer accepted | 10c/gal at Exxon and Mobil (12c premium) for existing cardholders | Closed-loop (Exxon/Mobil only) |
| BP Rewards Visa | Yes | 15c/gal at BP and Amoco; points (not cents per gallon) everywhere else | Visa (open-loop) |
Sources, checked 7 November 2026: bp rewards Visa (FNBO); ExxonMobil Smart Card+ FAQs.
Standing-Rate Savings on 50 Gallons a Month
Our model: cents per gallon x 50 gallons a month x 12 months, assuming every gallon is bought at the card's own brand. A cents-per-gallon discount does not depend on the pump price, so scale the gallons to match your own driving.
| Card | Cents per gallon | Per year (600 gallons) |
|---|---|---|
| ExxonMobil Smart Card+ (existing holders) | 10c | $60 |
| BP Rewards Visa | 15c | $90 |
Shell is left out of this table because we could not re-verify its current card discount against Shell or Citi this review.
The Three-Way Decision
Pick BP if: you fuel mostly at BP or Amoco and want a card you can apply for today. The 15 cents per gallon there is the highest standing rate of the cards we verified, and the Visa network means it works everywhere else too, earning points rather than a fuel discount.
ExxonMobil: if you already hold the Smart Card+, keep using it at Exxon and Mobil for 10 cents per gallon. If you do not, you cannot get it now; Direct Debit+ gives the same pump discount from a checking account.
Shell: worth a look if Shell is your usual station. Check Shell's current Fuel Rewards card terms for the per-gallon figure and any gallon limit before you apply.
The honest geographic test for any branded card: does the brand have a station on your commute and near home? If you would have to drive out of your way to reach one, a general-purpose gas card that pays a percentage at every station is simpler. See the gas card rankings.
The Stacking Layer
Each brand runs a free loyalty program that can stack with its card: Shell Fuel Rewards, BPme Rewards and Exxon Mobil Rewards+. Exxon Mobil Rewards+ pays 3 cents per gallon in points on regular fuel and 6 cents on premium, with 100 points worth $1, and ExxonMobil says it stacks with the Smart Card+. Smart Card+ plus Rewards+ on regular is 13 cents per gallon.
Cash-back apps such as Upside and GasBuddy add another optional layer at participating stations. Their offers vary by station and day, so check the app at the pump rather than counting on a fixed rate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still get all three cards?+
Which has the strongest standing rate?+
Which works as a general-purpose card outside the brand?+
Do the intro offers matter?+
Can I hold more than one?+
Related on This Site
Shell Fuel Rewards Mastercard
Full Shell card review.
ExxonMobil Smart Card+
Full ExxonMobil card review.
BP Rewards Visa
Full BP card review.
Why Oil-Company Cards Have Higher APR
Structural context.
Stacking Gas Rewards
Layer station loyalty plus credit card discount.
Citi Custom Cash
The general-purpose 5 percent alternative.